• Reasonable People
    • Joe Bast
    • Jim Lakely
    • David Applegate
    • Kendall Antekeier
    • Diane Carol Bast
    • Drew Banks
    • Andrew Barr
    • Bruno Behrend
    • Ben Boychuk
    • Alan Caruba
    • Edmund Contoski
    • Peter Ferrara
    • Matthew Glans
    • Jim Johnston
    • Jay Lehr
    • Maureen Martin
    • John Nothdurft
    • Joy Pullmann
    • James H. Rust
    • Harrison Schmitt
    • Taylor Smith
    • James M. Taylor
    • Rich Trzupek
    • Bruce Edward Walker
  • The Heartland Institute
  • Heartlander Magazine

Somewhat Reasonable

  • FacebookFacebook
  • TwitterTwitter
  • YoutubeYoutube
  • RSSRSS
  • itunesitunes
  • Budgets/Taxes
  • Environment/Energy
  • Education
  • Finance/Insurance/Real Estate
  • Health Care
  • Internet/Telecom
  • Legal Affairs

0

Education

The Most Persuasive Graph in the Education Debate

  • by Bruno Behrend
  • October 14, 2010
Tweet

With state and federal revenues crashing in the “great recession,” proponents of transforming America’s awful education system have a powerful new weapon.  Better yet, it is a double-edged sword that cuts in our favor in two powerful ways.

To illustrate, let’s look at the graph to the right. (Thank you, Cato Institute.)

Here’s what it means:

First, it utterly destroys the argument that they need more money.  They’ve had scads of money spent on education, and their results are flat (and that’s generous, when you consider how state standards and texts have been generally dumbed-down over the decades).

Second, it is now easy to illustrate that the “Government/Education Complex” has played a large role in the massive budget crises facing many states.  Indeed, if the costs had only stayed even with test scores, the recession may not even have occurred, as households would have much more cash on hand, instead of renting their houses from the school district.

If  someone asks you for the solution to the education problem, just tell them we need to fund children, not districts.

Tags: Fund Children-Not Bureaucracy

— Bruno Behrend

Bruno Behrend, J.D., is director of the Center for School Reform at The Heartland Institute. From early 2006 through late 2008, Behrend hosted a radio show in the Chicago area that showcased authors and policy specialists including publisher Steve Forbes, columnist Mark Steyn, author Shelby Steele, and many others. In 2008, Behrend coauthored Illinois Deserves Better - The Ironclad Case for an Illinois Constitutional Convention, the release of which coincided with a campaign to pass a referendum calling for a Constitutional Convention in Illinois. Mr. Behrend has served as an advisor to groups seeking to rewrite the legislative article of the Illinois Constitution and as Field Director for FreedomWorks in Illinois. In 2009, he was policy director for a gubernatorial candidate in the Illinois primary election.

  • Previous story Four Words: ‘Less Generous Benefit Packages’
  • Next story President Obama? Oh, He’s So Last Year

    Related Posts

  • “Free & Reduced Lunch” or “Costly & Reduced Effectiveness”? “Free & Reduced Lunch” or “Costly & Reduced Effectiveness”? November 9, 2010
  • Lawless Bureaucrats vs. Special Needs Kids in Oklahoma Lawless Bureaucrats vs. Special Needs Kids in Oklahoma November 17, 2010
  • My two cents on Russo’s Parent Trigger post My two cents on Russo’s Parent Trigger post December 17, 2010
  • Reasonable People

    Publisher/PresidentEditor-in-Chief
    Joe BastJim Lakely
    Contributors
    David ApplegateRalf Mangual
    Dave BanksMaureen Martin
    Diane Carol BastSeton Motley
    Alan CarubaJohn Nothdurft
    Paul ChesserJoy Pullmann
    Edmund ContoskiJames H. Rust
    Benjamin DomenechHarrison Schmitt
    Peter FerraraAlexandra Shanahan
    Matthew GlansTaylor Smith
    Jim JohnstonSteve Stanek
    Jay LehrJames M. Taylor
    S.T. KarnickBruce Edward Walker
  • HeartlandDonate2
  • Heartland on YouTube

    • Joseph Bast & Herbert Walberg: Education and Capitalism
      Joseph Bast & Herbert Walberg: Education and Capitalism
    • John Lott: At the Brink: Will Obama Push Us Over the Edge?
      John Lott: At the Brink: Will Obama Push Us Over the Edge?
    • Heartland
      Heartland's Jay Lehr on the Today Show: C02 Emissions (400 ppm)
  • RSS Somewhat Readable Links

    • iPencil | National Review Online
    • Eagle Scout Faces Felony for Honest Mistake
    • James Bovard: A Brief History of IRS Political Targeting - WSJ.com
    • The IRS Scandal: the Future of Big Government Is Now « Commentary Magazine
    • Lessons from the IRS scandal | Power Line
    • On the AP-Justice Department Story - Ricochet.com
    • Emptyage — Generation X Doesn't Want to Hear It
  • Obamacare Disaster
  • Tag Cloud

    2012 election al gore Barack-Obama budget California Chicago climate change climategate Congress debt ceiling economics economy education energy policy environment environmental protection agency EPA FCC federal budget fracking global warming green energy health care Heartland Institute internet liberty Medicaid Medicare Mitt Romney Obama Obamacare Paul Ryan Peter Ferrara politics Public Unions regulation school-reform scott walker Supreme Court Taxes teachers unions tea party unions Wisconsin Wisconsin protests
  • Heartland Websites

    The Heartland Institute
    The Heartlander
    Climate Conferences
    ClimateWiki
    Policybot
    The Parent Trigger
    Fakegate (Peter Gleick)

  • Heartland News

    Budget and Tax News
    Environment and Climate News
    FIRE Policy News
    Health Care News
    Infotech and Telecom News
    School Reform News
    Lawsuit Abuse

  • Get Reasonable

    About Us
    DONATE
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Youtube

  • Budgets/Taxes
  • Environment/Energy
  • Education
  • FIRE
  • Health Care
  • Internet/Telecom
  • Legal Affairs
  • FacebookFacebook
  • TwitterTwitter
  • YoutubeYoutube
  • RSSRSS
  • itunesitunes

Copyright The Heartland Institute