• Reasonable People
    • Joe Bast
    • Jim Lakely
    • David Applegate
    • Kendall Antekeier
    • Diane Carol Bast
    • Drew Banks
    • Andrew Barr
    • Bruno Behrend
    • Ben Boychuk
    • Alan Caruba
    • Edmund Contoski
    • Peter Ferrara
    • Matthew Glans
    • Jim Johnston
    • Jay Lehr
    • Maureen Martin
    • John Nothdurft
    • Joy Pullmann
    • James H. Rust
    • Harrison Schmitt
    • Taylor Smith
    • James M. Taylor
    • Rich Trzupek
    • Bruce Edward Walker
  • The Heartland Institute
  • Heartlander Magazine

Somewhat Reasonable

  • FacebookFacebook
  • TwitterTwitter
  • YoutubeYoutube
  • RSSRSS
  • itunesitunes
  • Budgets/Taxes
  • Environment/Energy
  • Education
  • Finance/Insurance/Real Estate
  • Health Care
  • Internet/Telecom
  • Legal Affairs

1

Media · Politics

The Left Refuses to Walk Back from its Blood Libel

  • by Jim Lakely
  • January 17, 2011
Tweet

James Eric Fuller (above) allegedly threatened a Tea Party activist at a "healing" event in Tucson.

We are now past one week from the day a psychotic man brought tragic death and injury  to Tucson, Arizona. It is now a well-documented fact that Jared Loughner listened to only the impenetrable and evil demons in his head, and not to any particular talk radio show host or a politician.

As I wrote on this blog a few days ago, I hated even thinking that the left and the “mainstream media” would so quickly exploit the tragedy to libel the Tea Party movement, Sarah Palin and anyone who vocally opposed the left’s vision of America. But, alas, that was the case.

Indeed, it is a sick (but, perhaps, apt) irony, that one of the victims of the shooting showed up at an ABC television event to yell “you’re dead” at a Tea Party spokesman in attendance.That man, James Eric Fuller, has been “involuntarily committed to an undisclosed medical facility.” Why would Fuller make such a threat toward a Tea Party activist?

Until we know Fuller’s psychological profile at least as well as we now do Loughner’s, the jury’s out. But, if we are to use the standards of evidence the MSM/left employed in the day of the shooting, we can say that Fuller’s motivations are linked much more strongly to the MSM/left’s blood libel than Loughner’s motivations were ever sensibly linked to the Tea Party and Palin. From the Associated Press:

Grief-stricken after the Tucson supermarket massacre, shooting victim James Eric Fuller found comfort in writing down the Declaration of Independence from memory while recovering in a hospital.

The self-described liberal and military veteran became distraught Saturday and began ranting at the end of a televised town hall meeting about the shooting. He took a picture of Tucson Tea Party co-founder Trent Humphries and yelled, “You’re dead” before calling others in the church a bunch of “whores,” authorities said.

He was arrested and taken to a hospital for a mental evaluation.

In media interviews and on the Internet, Fuller, a former limousine driver and census worker, has said he worked hard to get Rep. Gabrielle Giffords re-elected, and was going over questions he had prepared for her when the shooting began. He was shot in the knee and back and spent two days in the hospital.

We may know the truth of Fuller’s motivations in time — and we pray for his swift recovery, both physical and psychological. Meanwhile, we can still note the efforts by the MSM and the left his past week to pretend the shooting had anything to do with non-left politics.

James Taranto at the WSJ has done a fantastic job rebutting the blood libel the left has imposed on the Tea Party and Palin. Jonah Goldberg has a great column on the matter. Jonathan S. Tobin has an interesting take at the Contentions blog. And John Steele Gordon (also at Contentions) has a good breakdown on madness of The New York Times‘ Paul Krugman on this issue.

The point we all are making is that the MSM/left has exploited this tragic incident to achieve what they have not yet been able to accomplish — getting the bulk of America to agree that opposition the recent and aggressive dash towards statism is not only wrong-headed, but literally, dangerous.

It is said that the remedy for “bad” speech is more speech. I endorse that maxim here — as we all must.

Tags: Jared Loughnernew york timesTucson

— Jim Lakely

Jim is the the director of communications at The Heartland Institute. Prior to joining Heartland, he was an ink-stained newspaperman for 16 years with many stops in "old media." Jim covered Congress and The White House during the George W. Bush administration for The Washington Times, and worked as a reporter, editorial writer and columnist for newspapers in Pennsylvania, Virginia, and California. He has appeared on the Fox News Channel, CNN, MSNBC, C-Span, and many local and national talk radio shows to talk politics and policy.

  • Previous story Restaurant Owners Keep Food Truck Competitors On the Run
  • Next story Heartland Institute Statement on Merger of Comcast and NBC/Universal

    Related Posts

  • Leave It To The Global Warming Alarmists To Make Fake Lemonade Out Of Hurricane Sandy Leave It To The Global Warming Alarmists To Make Fake Lemonade Out Of Hurricane Sandy November 3, 2012
  • whpc Turning on Obama — Could it Be That the Liberal Press has Finally Figured Him Out? May 9, 2013
  • WikiLeaks Vs. ClimateGate at The New York Times WikiLeaks Vs. ClimateGate at The New York Times November 29, 2010
  • NYTimes: When we said Fracking Frequently Contaminates Drinking Water, We Meant it That it Didn’t at All NYTimes: When we said Fracking Frequently Contaminates Drinking Water, We Meant it That it Didn’t at All May 20, 2011
  • http://www.saveourschools-ca.org Josh For Education

    All this drama about the violence is important, but it obscures the larger issues. One of the most important school problems, in my opinion, is the low, low level of funding. See http://www.saveourschools-ca.org for more.

  • Reasonable People

    Publisher/PresidentContributing Editors
    Joe BastDiane Carol Bast
    Bruno Behrend
    Editor-in-ChiefBen Boychuk
    Jim LakelyBenjamin Domenech
    Contributors
    David ApplegateS.T. Karnick
    Dave BanksMaureen Martin
    Alan CarubaJohn Nothdurft
    Paul ChesserJoy Pullmann
    Edmund ContoskiJames H. Rust
    Keely DrukalaHarrison Schmitt
    Peter FerraraTaylor Smith
    Matthew GlansSteve Stanek
    Jim JohnstonJames M. Taylor
    Jay LehrBruce Edward Walker
  • Heartland on YouTube

    • Joseph Bast & Herbert Walberg: Education and Capitalism
      Joseph Bast & Herbert Walberg: Education and Capitalism
    • John Lott: At the Brink: Will Obama Push Us Over the Edge?
      John Lott: At the Brink: Will Obama Push Us Over the Edge?
    • Heartland
      Heartland's Jay Lehr on the Today Show: C02 Emissions (400 ppm)
  • RSS Somewhat Readable Links

    • iPencil | National Review Online
    • Eagle Scout Faces Felony for Honest Mistake
    • James Bovard: A Brief History of IRS Political Targeting - WSJ.com
    • The IRS Scandal: the Future of Big Government Is Now « Commentary Magazine
    • Lessons from the IRS scandal | Power Line
    • On the AP-Justice Department Story - Ricochet.com
    • Emptyage — Generation X Doesn't Want to Hear It
  • Obamacare Disaster
  • Tag Cloud

    2012 election al gore Barack-Obama budget California Chicago climate change climategate Congress debt ceiling economics education energy policy environment environmental protection agency EPA FCC federal budget federal spending fracking global warming green energy health care Heartland Institute internet liberty Medicaid Medicare Mitt Romney Obama Obamacare Paul Ryan Peter Ferrara politics Public Unions regulation school-reform scott walker Supreme Court Taxes teachers unions tea party unions Wisconsin Wisconsin protests
  • Heartland Websites

    The Heartland Institute
    The Heartlander
    Climate Conferences
    ClimateWiki
    Policybot
    The Parent Trigger
    Fakegate (Peter Gleick)

  • Heartland News

    Budget and Tax News
    Environment and Climate News
    FIRE Policy News
    Health Care News
    Infotech and Telecom News
    School Reform News
    Lawsuit Abuse

  • Get Reasonable

    About Us
    DONATE
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Youtube

  • Budgets/Taxes
  • Environment/Energy
  • Education
  • FIRE
  • Health Care
  • Internet/Telecom
  • Legal Affairs
  • FacebookFacebook
  • TwitterTwitter
  • YoutubeYoutube
  • RSSRSS
  • itunesitunes

Copyright The Heartland Institute