• Reasonable People
    • Joe Bast
    • Jim Lakely
    • David Applegate
    • Kendall Antekeier
    • Diane Carol Bast
    • Drew Banks
    • Andrew Barr
    • Bruno Behrend
    • Ben Boychuk
    • Alan Caruba
    • Edmund Contoski
    • Peter Ferrara
    • Matthew Glans
    • Jim Johnston
    • Jay Lehr
    • Maureen Martin
    • John Nothdurft
    • Joy Pullmann
    • James H. Rust
    • Harrison Schmitt
    • Taylor Smith
    • James M. Taylor
    • Rich Trzupek
    • Bruce Edward Walker
  • The Heartland Institute
  • Heartlander Magazine

Somewhat Reasonable

  • FacebookFacebook
  • TwitterTwitter
  • YoutubeYoutube
  • RSSRSS
  • itunesitunes
  • Budgets/Taxes
  • Environment/Energy
  • Education
  • Finance/Insurance/Real Estate
  • Health Care
  • Internet/Telecom
  • Legal Affairs

2

Economics · Liberty · Politics

An Astronaut’s View on The Debt Ceiling Debate

  • by Harrison Schmitt
  • July 29, 2011
Tweet

(Reactions to recent events by Harrison Schmitt — Heartland Institute Board member, former U.S. Senator (R-N.M.), and the last man (and first scientist) to set foot on the moon. (Cross-posted at America’s Uncommon Sense):

The political struggles surrounding the potential breaching of the current limit on debt that can be incurred by the United States Government, and the underlying unsustainable levels of federal spending and taxation, have distinct similarities to other momentous struggles in our history. These earlier challenges all involved those who fought to establish and/or preserve human liberty against those with ideological opposition to that liberty.

In our Founders’ late 18th and early 19th Century fight for Independence and its preservation, the forces of liberty were opposed by an ideology advocating the divine right of Kings. In the 1860’s Civil War to free the slaves, the forces of liberty were opposed by the ideology that condoned slavery.

In the World Wars of the early and mid 20th Century, the forces of liberty opposed an ideology of social and racial superiority underpinned by Prussian and German National Socialism. In the Cold War that followed World War II, the forces of liberty opposed a communist ideology that would suppress all liberty except that of an elite governing minority. The common theme running through these four struggles was liberty versus tyranny.

In this current fight over the debt limit and federal spending and taxation, a homegrown combination of national socialism and communism has come to the fore, aided and abetted by “crony” capitalists now dependent on federal funding and regulation. That combined assault on Americans would sacrifice constitutional protections of liberty and natural rights as well as the economic future of generations yet to come in order to preserve an elitist minority’s power to govern.

Winning the debt limit and federal spending and taxation reduction battle constitutes one more component of America’s continuing responsibility to preserve human liberty. Unfortunately, the President has indicated that, if the debt limit is not raised, he will not carry out his constitutional responsibility under both his Article II executive and law enforcement duties and his 14th Amendment, Section 4, mandate to use available revenues to service the debts and other essential obligations of the United States. As now noted by some in Congress, this constitutes an impeachable offense, not that this fact bothers the President. This clearly means, however, that Barack Obama should not be re-elected in 2012.

The House of Representatives has the responsibility to repeatedly force the Senate and the President to consider a coupled debt limit extension and spending and tax reductions (Cut, Cap and Balance) even if the President refuses to sign such a bill into law. Under Article I, Section 8, Clause 1 of the Constitution, only the Congress is empowered “to pay the Debts…of the United States…” and any move by the President to ignore or extend the debt limit without legislation from Congress would be unconstitutional. In the event that the debt limit is not raised, the House also should force the Senate to repeatedly consider bills requiring payments from existing tax revenues to military personnel and veterans, Border Patrol and Coast Guard personnel, internal and external intelligence services, as well as American citizens currently dependent on Social Security income.

Win or lose in this battle of the debt limit and reductions in federal spending and taxes, we must assume that 2012 will be the final opportunity for the forces of liberty to live up to their responsibility to the future of humankind.

Tags: debt ceilingfounding fathersharrison schmittnational debt

— Harrison Schmitt

Harrison Schmitt, former astronaut and U.S. Senator (R-N.M.), joined The Heartland Institute’s board of directors effective January 28, 2010. Schmitt received his bachelor’s degree from Caltech and studied as a Fulbright Scholar in Oslo, Norway. He earned his Ph.D. in geology from Harvard University in 1964. As a civilian, Schmitt received Air Force jet pilot wings in 1965 and Navy helicopter wings in 1967. Selected for the scientist-astronaut program in 1965, Schmitt organized the lunar science training for the Apollo astronauts and served as Mission Scientist in support of the Apollo 11 mission. After training as back-up Lunar Module Pilot for Apollo 15, Schmitt flew in space as Lunar Module Pilot for Apollo 17, the last Apollo mission to the moon. On December 11, 1972, he landed in the Valley of Taurus-Littrow as the only scientist and the last of 12 men to step on the Moon.

  • Previous story Happy Birthday, Milton Friedman
  • Next story The Latest Insanity from California: Orange Punch Update

    Related Posts

  • R.I.P. Neil Armstrong, American Hero R.I.P. Neil Armstrong, American Hero August 25, 2012
  • Great News! Fed Economists Predict Gloom! Great News! Fed Economists Predict Gloom! August 10, 2011
  • Money Madness, The Fed and the National Debt Money Madness, The Fed and the National Debt July 24, 2011
  • Heartland Institute Experts React to Tuesday’s Debt Ceiling Vote in Senate Heartland Institute Experts React to Tuesday’s Debt Ceiling Vote in Senate August 3, 2011
  • Arroyoribera

    What kind of work has Schmitt done and what income has he earned outside the of government-run agencies and organizations?  Has he ever had health insurance other than “socialist” government provided health insurance?  If so, I don’t see any reference in his bio above. .

    • http://somewhatreasonable.com/ Jim_Lakely

      Schmitt’s full bio is too large to post here. But he’s worked in the private sector for decades after his NASA and Senate careers ended.

  • Reasonable People

    Publisher/PresidentContributing Editors
    Joe BastDiane Carol Bast
    Bruno Behrend
    Editor-in-ChiefBen Boychuk
    Jim LakelyBenjamin Domenech
    Contributors
    David ApplegateS.T. Karnick
    Dave BanksMaureen Martin
    Alan CarubaJohn Nothdurft
    Paul ChesserJoy Pullmann
    Edmund ContoskiJames H. Rust
    Keely DrukalaHarrison Schmitt
    Peter FerraraTaylor Smith
    Matthew GlansSteve Stanek
    Jim JohnstonJames M. Taylor
    Jay LehrBruce Edward Walker
  • HeartlandDonate2
  • Heartland on YouTube

    • Joseph Bast & Herbert Walberg: Education and Capitalism
      Joseph Bast & Herbert Walberg: Education and Capitalism
    • John Lott: At the Brink: Will Obama Push Us Over the Edge?
      John Lott: At the Brink: Will Obama Push Us Over the Edge?
    • Heartland
      Heartland's Jay Lehr on the Today Show: C02 Emissions (400 ppm)
  • RSS Somewhat Readable Links

    • iPencil | National Review Online
    • Eagle Scout Faces Felony for Honest Mistake
    • James Bovard: A Brief History of IRS Political Targeting - WSJ.com
    • The IRS Scandal: the Future of Big Government Is Now « Commentary Magazine
    • Lessons from the IRS scandal | Power Line
    • On the AP-Justice Department Story - Ricochet.com
    • Emptyage — Generation X Doesn't Want to Hear It
  • Obamacare Disaster
  • Tag Cloud

    2012 election al gore Barack-Obama budget California Chicago climate change climategate Congress debt ceiling economics economy education energy policy environment environmental protection agency EPA FCC federal budget fracking global warming green energy health care Heartland Institute internet liberty Medicaid Medicare Mitt Romney Obama Obamacare Paul Ryan Peter Ferrara politics Public Unions regulation school-reform scott walker Supreme Court Taxes teachers unions tea party unions Wisconsin Wisconsin protests
  • Heartland Websites

    The Heartland Institute
    The Heartlander
    Climate Conferences
    ClimateWiki
    Policybot
    The Parent Trigger
    Fakegate (Peter Gleick)

  • Heartland News

    Budget and Tax News
    Environment and Climate News
    FIRE Policy News
    Health Care News
    Infotech and Telecom News
    School Reform News
    Lawsuit Abuse

  • Get Reasonable

    About Us
    DONATE
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Youtube

  • Budgets/Taxes
  • Environment/Energy
  • Education
  • FIRE
  • Health Care
  • Internet/Telecom
  • Legal Affairs
  • FacebookFacebook
  • TwitterTwitter
  • YoutubeYoutube
  • RSSRSS
  • itunesitunes

Copyright The Heartland Institute