• Reasonable People
    • Joe Bast
    • Jim Lakely
    • David Applegate
    • Kendall Antekeier
    • Diane Carol Bast
    • Drew Banks
    • Andrew Barr
    • Bruno Behrend
    • Ben Boychuk
    • Alan Caruba
    • Edmund Contoski
    • Peter Ferrara
    • Matthew Glans
    • Jim Johnston
    • Jay Lehr
    • Maureen Martin
    • John Nothdurft
    • Joy Pullmann
    • James H. Rust
    • Harrison Schmitt
    • Taylor Smith
    • James M. Taylor
    • Rich Trzupek
    • Bruce Edward Walker
  • The Heartland Institute
  • Heartlander Magazine

Somewhat Reasonable

  • FacebookFacebook
  • TwitterTwitter
  • YoutubeYoutube
  • RSSRSS
  • itunesitunes
  • Budgets/Taxes
  • Environment/Energy
  • Education
  • Finance/Insurance/Real Estate
  • Health Care
  • Internet/Telecom
  • Legal Affairs

3

Education · Media · Politics

Stars of ‘Won’t Back Down’ Reap Unexpected Teachers Union/Leftist Backlash

  • by Jim Lakely
  • September 28, 2012
Tweet

It appears that the stars of “Won’t Back Down,” which enjoys wide theatrical release today, had no idea they were participating in a movie that celebrated an idea that greatly annoys the left and Democrats — school choice via the Parent Trigger.

That fact is ironic, considering protagonist Maggie Gyllenhaal is an active and vocal member of the fashionable Hollywood left. Yet, to her credit, Gyllenhaal is sticking by her guns, and with the parent-empowerment message of her movie despite protests by teachers unions.

According to HotAir’s Mary Katherine Ham, clips of the film at the Democratic National Convention drew boos, and the president of the American Federation of Teachers wrote a letter of protest. But Gyllenhaal — who was “surprised” by the controversy of putting the needs of kids before the rules of bureaucrats and the demands of teachers unions — is not swayed (for now). She said the message of the movie is about kids, not teachers unions:

If the adults in this situation are disagreeing to such a point that we are not making the changes that we need to make in order to serve our kids, then we are all failing.

And if the Tweet below is to be believed, Gyllenhaal was defending her position late into the night on Thursday:

Viola Davis, who plays a reform-minded teacher in the film, also stood up for the movie’s message:

I welcome protests. I welcome discourse. I think discourse is a good thing. I think it spearheads change…. And you know what, in this movie, the teacher at the end of the day is the hero. They save the day. And it’s a system that’s broken, that needs to be fixed.

Good for Ms. Davis! And even the movie’s producer, Mark Johnson, who rejects the lefty protestors and sticks up for the movie’s message:

I am surprised. Maybe I’ve been naive about this, but I think it’s a David and Goliath story: two women, two mothers from completely different backgrounds who get involved in trying to do something about the sorry state of this particular school.

Yeah, Mark. I think you’re being naive about this. What is the worth of “two women, two mothers from completely different backgrounds” against the teachers unions and the leviathan of the education bureaucracy? The parents are nothing. The bureaucracy is everything. I think, Mark, you’re going to find that making this movie was more trouble than it was worth.

I hope I’m wrong. I bet my wife that Gyllenhaal would recant her stance on this film and its message by the end of the weekend. Perhaps it will take longer. She may have to recant three times to satisfy the religion of the left. Perhaps it will merely take an Oprah appearance. We’ll see.

If you want to get the skinny on the policy behind this movie, no one does it better than The Heartland Institute. Check out our Parent Trigger website for starters. And there’s more information on Heartland’s “ideas” page on the Parent Trigger, as well — including many articles and several podcasts over the past two years.

And stay tuned for a new policy paper on the Parent Trigger, slated for release next week. When this whole revolutionary idea got started in 2010, we were all over it with a comprehensive study.

Tags: maggie gyllenhaalParent Triggerviola daviswon't back down

— Jim Lakely

Jim is the the director of communications at The Heartland Institute. Prior to joining Heartland, he was an ink-stained newspaperman for 16 years with many stops in "old media." Jim covered Congress and The White House during the George W. Bush administration for The Washington Times, and worked as a reporter, editorial writer and columnist for newspapers in Pennsylvania, Virginia, and California. He has appeared on the Fox News Channel, CNN, MSNBC, C-Span, and many local and national talk radio shows to talk politics and policy.

  • Previous story Taylor at Forbes: Antarctic Sea Ice Sets Another Record
  • Next story Taylor at Forbes: 100 Million Examples of Global Warming Absurdity

    Related Posts

  • Rahm Emanuel Needs to Pull ‘Mayor Trigger’ Rahm Emanuel Needs to Pull ‘Mayor Trigger’ November 23, 2012
  • My two cents on Russo’s Parent Trigger post My two cents on Russo’s Parent Trigger post December 17, 2010
  • If you’re debating layoffs, you aren’t serious about transforming education If you’re debating layoffs, you aren’t serious about transforming education February 25, 2011
  • In Compton, Scissors Beat Rock, Paper Beats Scissors, and a Staple Beats a ‘Trigger’ In Compton, Scissors Beat Rock, Paper Beats Scissors, and a Staple Beats a ‘Trigger’ March 2, 2011
  • Joy Pullmann

    I think Maggie sticks to her guns. But, as we saw with the Rotten Tomatoes discussion on the podcast, I tend to err on the side of over-positive thinking.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1049165963 Donna Goldcamp

    We loved the film and I recommend it to all. If the story embarrasses the left and Teachers’ Unions too bad. The children come first. Good for Viola Davis and Maggie Gyllenhaal!!!

    • http://somewhatreasonable.com/ Jim_Lakely

      Thanks, Donna. Check out our discussion about the film in the Friday edition of the Heartland Daily Podcast.

      http://blog.heartland.org/2012/09/heartland-daily-podcast-pullmann-and-boychuk-on-wont-back-down/

  • Reasonable People

    Publisher/PresidentContributing Editors
    Joe BastDiane Carol Bast
    Bruno Behrend
    Editor-in-ChiefBen Boychuk
    Jim LakelyBenjamin Domenech
    Contributors
    David ApplegateS.T. Karnick
    Dave BanksMaureen Martin
    Alan CarubaJohn Nothdurft
    Paul ChesserJoy Pullmann
    Edmund ContoskiJames H. Rust
    Keely DrukalaHarrison Schmitt
    Peter FerraraTaylor Smith
    Matthew GlansSteve Stanek
    Jim JohnstonJames M. Taylor
    Jay LehrBruce Edward Walker
  • Heartland on YouTube

    • Joseph Bast & Herbert Walberg: Education and Capitalism
      Joseph Bast & Herbert Walberg: Education and Capitalism
    • John Lott: At the Brink: Will Obama Push Us Over the Edge?
      John Lott: At the Brink: Will Obama Push Us Over the Edge?
    • Heartland
      Heartland's Jay Lehr on the Today Show: C02 Emissions (400 ppm)
  • RSS Somewhat Readable Links

    • iPencil | National Review Online
    • Eagle Scout Faces Felony for Honest Mistake
    • James Bovard: A Brief History of IRS Political Targeting - WSJ.com
    • The IRS Scandal: the Future of Big Government Is Now « Commentary Magazine
    • Lessons from the IRS scandal | Power Line
    • On the AP-Justice Department Story - Ricochet.com
    • Emptyage — Generation X Doesn't Want to Hear It
  • Obamacare Disaster
  • Tag Cloud

    2012 election al gore Barack-Obama budget California Chicago climate change climategate Congress debt ceiling economics economy education energy policy environment environmental protection agency EPA FCC federal budget fracking global warming green energy health care Heartland Institute internet liberty Medicaid Medicare Mitt Romney Obama Obamacare Paul Ryan Peter Ferrara politics Public Unions regulation school-reform scott walker Supreme Court Taxes teachers unions tea party unions Wisconsin Wisconsin protests
  • Heartland Websites

    The Heartland Institute
    The Heartlander
    Climate Conferences
    ClimateWiki
    Policybot
    The Parent Trigger
    Fakegate (Peter Gleick)

  • Heartland News

    Budget and Tax News
    Environment and Climate News
    FIRE Policy News
    Health Care News
    Infotech and Telecom News
    School Reform News
    Lawsuit Abuse

  • Get Reasonable

    About Us
    DONATE
    Facebook
    Twitter
    Youtube

  • Budgets/Taxes
  • Environment/Energy
  • Education
  • FIRE
  • Health Care
  • Internet/Telecom
  • Legal Affairs
  • FacebookFacebook
  • TwitterTwitter
  • YoutubeYoutube
  • RSSRSS
  • itunesitunes

Copyright The Heartland Institute